
Charles Henderson
EVP, Cyber Security Services, Coalfire
While many in the cybersecurity community know me and the body of work my teams have performed over the last twenty years, those outside the industry might not know me well. I’m a hacker. I have been all my life. And for the last two decades, I’ve led the world’s best hackers and defenders. From Trustwave SpiderLabs, to IBM X-Force, to here at Coalfire DivisionHex, my teams have worked almost exclusively in large enterprise environments. I’ve also served on the Black Hat Review Board since 2022 and have advised cybersecurity startups since 2018.
My teams have helped secure the vast majority of Fortune 500 companies, including nearly all major tech companies. We’ve helped the Federal government be more secure. My current team has a dedicated R&D function; we have expanded access to multiple frontier models with cyber capabilities, and we predicted the acceleration that’s driving these events back in April. All of this to say, my team and I have seen it all. Frankly, we wish we hadn’t seen some of it.
If you want to know what’s going on, you must first understand how IT works in major enterprises and organizations that support critical infrastructure. For decades now, security teams have been identifying vulnerabilities in software. The typical pattern: find a bug, vendor creates a patch, enterprise deploys the patch. What has changed in recent years is that large language models have accelerated the speed at which security teams can find these software bugs. This means that software vendors are creating a higher volume of patches, and enterprise IT teams have more fixing to do than ever. As an example, one “patch Tuesday” earlier this October addressed more than 1400 vulnerabilities.
There is real urgency to deploy those patches, but not for the reason you might think. As it turns out, while the rate of vulnerability discovery is accelerating, the rate of attackers exploiting those vulnerabilities is largely flat. The theme from many CISOs I talk to is the same as it is every year: we’re trying to get this done before the IT change freeze goes into effect.
Nearly every major enterprise implements a freeze on IT changes at the end of the year. As a result, October and November are crunch time for those organizations trying to squeeze in any remaining changes.
The fact is that there is no reported evidence that any of these (much less most of these) interruptions of service are related to malicious cyber attacks, but rather the result of squeezing in additional changes, including defenses against potential future attacks.
The crush of work on those IT teams, the well documented issues surrounding vibe coding, and the extremely intricate nature of some of these enterprise environments can create a perfect storm for unexpected effects that result in degradation of services and outages.
But that’s not to say that there haven’t been any attacks. Attacks happen all day, every day. It’s been that way for a very long time now. You may have heard of the ARTEX framework, the subject of a recent FBI FLASH report. Like we called out earlier this year with the release of Mythos, the ARTEX threat activity represents another milestone in the ability for skilled attackers to move more quickly, and at a larger scale than before. But make no mistake, ARTEX doesn’t turn an unskilled individual into a super hacker. And while yes, zero days have been exploited by actors (again, not new), we have not seen threat actors use AI to execute novel end-to-end attacks.
Every time a major framework is released, you see attackers using it. This was the case with Metasploit in the 2000s, then Cobalt Strike, then PowerShell Empire. Each time, alarmists screeched it was the end of the world. As it turns out, the world is remarkably resilient. Even if attackers are leveraging LLMs to assist in automating activities, it’s still executing routine attacks like SQL injection. It’s still relying on PowerShell and “LOLBins.” We’re not seeing novelty in these attacks. Again, as we predicted in April, attackers are doing the same things they’ve always done, simply faster.
The bane of my team’s existence has been how the frontier labs have approached cybersecurity. While vulnerability discovery is one important aspect of cybersecurity, that would be like saying the best doctor in the world is one who simply diagnosed a patient with a disease then walked away. It’s like they’ve treated cybersecurity entirely as a bug-finding exercise.
Like all experienced cybersecurity practitioners know, diagnosis is only the start of the solution. Triage, prioritization contextualized to the enterprise, deployment of patching, and assisting defenders in detection and response of threats are all much larger strategic issues that the frontier labs have not meaningfully contributed to solving. If we are going to deal with a changing threat landscape with minimal disruptions, we should all be expecting more from them. A great starting point would be assisting defenders in detecting and responding to threats faster and more cost effectively.
Up to this point, I’ve said a lot about not worrying. The bad news is that a more prominent cyber event will eventually happen. It’s evergreen advice that my clients have received from me for years now: it’s only a matter of time before you’ll be compromised.
The same is true on a more macro scale. What threats want, whether cybercriminal or state-sponsored, is for you to connect a real incident to unrelated outages because it multiplies your fear. It plays directly into their hands.
No doubt you’ve seen the “cybersecurity experts” who themselves are assisting in the spreading of fear, uncertainty, and doubt without evidence to support their claims. This is incredibly disappointing to me. Fear is an extremely useful tool to steer people’s behavior. What you should be asking is, how do the same people who spread fear benefit from their alarmism? If you come across these posts, check their bios to see which funds or cybersecurity product companies they’re invested in that would benefit from their fearmongering. Their motives will become clear (yes, I see the irony of a guy who sells security services telling you not to panic; that’s kind of the point).
At the end of the day, this is an entirely solvable problem. My team has sat alongside security teams in finance, tech, healthcare, retail, and critical infrastructure and helped them accelerate their own security improvement. And while there’s plenty of work left to do, we truly feel there is every reason to fear no future. So, as we approach Thanksgiving, feel free to unplug, spend time with loved ones, and enjoy some time away from screens. We all need it.